Open Source

      Many open source tools are available to monitor a LAN.  Do you believe these open source tools are as effective as the commercial of the shelf products? Are they as safe?  Are there hidden security risks within the open source products that the end user does not know about?


My initial response should be taken with a grain of salt.  I  haven’t been able to afford paid software like Observium, so I don’t have a valid basis for comparison, but after trying to install Nagios, and Cactii, and LibreSNMP and finally settling on the clunky and annoying Spiceworks Network Monitor, I am inclined to think that while effective, and potentially as powerful as paid software, the Open Source Freeware is probably not the most usable option, and an administrator would probably save himself a lot of headache by purchasing a program that would probably pay for itself many times over within the first year. 

I can imagine that there would be some sort of security risks inherent in any network monitoring programs, but from what I’ve been able to tell, there are as many people that love reporting on security flaws as there are that love exploiting them, so I would assert that Open Source Software, when properly reviewed and vetted, is as safe as any other software on the market. 

Leave a Comment